Imagine handing a hockey referee a dictionary and asking for an offside call. The entry would be accurate enough: a player is offside when they are somewhere the rules do not allow. It would also be no help at all at the blue line. The word offside appears in the rulebooks of hockey, soccer, rugby and gridiron football, and each game defines it differently. A referee makes the call by knowing which game is being played.
The key terms in a Theory of Knowledge title behave the same way. “Evidence,” “strong,” and “recent” mean one thing in a laboratory and something completely different in an archive. Yet many essays still open by quoting a dictionary, as if one definition could serve every game at once.
This post shows how to define key terms in a ToK essay so that they do real work in the areas of knowledge you are writing about. (Whistle not included.)
Why the dictionary falls short
A dictionary records how a word is used across every context at once. That is its job, and it does it well. Your essay needs something narrower: the meaning a term carries in this title, in these two areas of knowledge. A dictionary opening also spends precious words without making a claim, and examiners tend to read it as throat-clearing.
The philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein put the underlying point memorably:
For a large class of cases — though not for all — in which we employ the word “meaning” it can be defined thus: the meaning of a word is its use in the language.
Ludwig Wittgenstein, Philosophical Investigations, §43 (trans. G. E. M. Anscombe)
Notice that he stops himself before going offside (“though not for all”); even his account of meaning is carefully calibrated. Wittgenstein called these settings of use language-games, which brings us close to the offside problem. The word stays the same, and the game decides what it means.
I learned this first-hand. My genetics degree spent most of its first two years teaching me how words are used in scientific research and publication. Only in third and fourth year, and in graduate studies for those who went on, did the deeper conversations become possible. By then, students were fluent enough for nuance. I remember the level of discussion in some of the senior courses was much closer to a scientific symposium - a discussion amongst peers - than a professor dispensing knowledge.
One particular class stands out in my memory - the professor would bring us articles freshly published in scientific journals on a Friday, then say he hadn’t even read them yet, but we’d all dissect them together on Monday. We had absorbed enough of the rules and meanings of words in the study of genetics that we were able to have meaningful discussions that reflected the nuances of the body of knowledge in the field of study. (Worth noting - even within an area of knowledge like the natural sciences, there are various disciplines that use similar words to convey different meanings - a nucleus in biology and a nucleus in physics are talking about vastly different entities!)
ToK students are in the midst of immersion in several language-games; each subject group in the IB Programme has one, and some have dialects of their own. Defining terms in context is how an essay shows it can speak each one well enough to hold the conversation the title asks for.
How to define key terms in a ToK essay: four steps
- Choose the terms that carry the argument. There are usually two or three. If you unpacked the title first, they are among the words you circled. Instructions such as “discuss” rarely need defining.
- Ask “which rulebook?” Define each key term within a particular area of knowledge. A term that sits comfortably in the natural sciences may behave quite differently in history or the arts.
- Define by use. This is Wittgenstein’s point put to work. Ask how the term is tested, measured, or judged in that area, and what a practitioner (a chemist, a historian) would count as a case of it. (But don’t mention Wittgenstein gratuitously; name-dropping earns no extra points.)
- Note where the rulebooks differ. If your two areas use a term differently, you have found something worth writing about. That difference is often where the essay’s argument starts.
A definition in a ToK essay is usually a sentence or two, placed where the term first does work, rather than a glossary at the top.
Once a definition is set, keep it steady. An essay that quietly shifts the meaning of “strongest” between paragraphs is changing the rules at halftime, and readers notice. (Hockey has periods, of course; the principle survives the translation.)
Worked example: defining “strongest evidence” in a May 2024 title
We return to the past prescribed title this series has been following:
Are we too quick to assume that the most recent evidence is inevitably the strongest? Discuss with reference to the natural sciences and one other area of knowledge.
The terms carrying the argument are “recent” and “strongest,” with “evidence” holding them together. Taking history as the second area, we can read each term by two rulebooks.
Natural sciences. Strength tends to be judged by precision, controlled conditions and, above all, replication: a result counts for more once independent teams have reproduced it. “Recent” usually refers to when the data were gathered or published. That gives recent evidence an awkward disadvantage, since it has had the least time to be tested.
History. Strength depends more on provenance (who produced a source, when, and why) and on corroboration across independent sources. “Recent” can mean two quite different things here: a newly opened archive full of much older documents, or a new interpretation of familiar ones. The first kind is recent to us and old in itself.
What defining sounds like
A weaker definition:
According to the dictionary, evidence is “the available body of facts or information indicating whether a belief or proposition is true or valid.” In this essay, the strongest evidence will be the evidence that best shows something is true.
A stronger one:
In the natural sciences, the strength of evidence tends to be judged by precision and replication, so recent results start at a disadvantage: they have had less time to be reproduced. In history, strength rests more on provenance and corroboration, and “recent” might describe a newly available source or a new reading of an old one. These standards differ, and the difference shapes how I will approach the title.
The weaker version borrows a general rulebook, then defines “strongest” in a circle. It applies one definition to both areas and never mentions “recent” at all. The stronger version defines each term by how it is used in each area, and in doing so it has already found a tension: recency counts against evidence in one rulebook and is ambiguous in the other. It has not yet decided how to interpret the whole title. That comes next.
Common traps
- Opening with a dictionary quotation. It fills the first paragraph and rarely earns its place.
- Defining every word. Only the terms whose meanings shift between areas of knowledge need it.
- Using one definition for both areas, when the areas plainly use the term differently.
- Shifting a definition midway through the essay.
- Defining a term so the argument wins itself. If “strongest” means “most recent” by definition, the title has nothing left to ask. Choosing a fair interpretation is the subject of the next post.
Try it: write your rulebook
- List the two or three key terms in your chosen title.
- For each term, write one sentence on how it is used in your first area of knowledge, and one for your second.
- Underline any place where the two sentences disagree.
- Bring that disagreement to your next conversation with your teacher; it may well become the spine of your essay.
Before the whistle
Next in this series: Choosing and Justifying Your Interpretation.
A referee who knows which game is being played can make a hard call quickly, and defend it when the crowd objects. Your essay needs the same footing. Once you know which rulebook each key term belongs to, the difficult calls in your argument become ones you can make and justify. (The dictionary can stay in the stands.)
At The ToK Café, we check which game we’re playing.
